The argument is almost as old as the creation/evolution controversy itself. Creationists have long charged that evolutionists date the fossils using circular reasoning in their dating methods. That is to say, on one hand, they date the layers of geological strata by the so-called “index fossils” found within them. (Of course index fossils are not always reliable standards, as is evident from such creatures as coelacanths, trilobites, and even frogs—a point made by Blair Hedges in an article in the October 16, 2003 issue of Nature titled “The Coelacanth of Frogs.”) Then, on the other hand, evolutionists date fossils according to the strata in which they are found.
Evolutionists routinely deny the charge that they use circular reasoning. As one article titled “Radiometric Dating and the Geological Time Scale” on the evolutionary site, www.TalkOrigins.com, commented:
The unfortunate part of the natural process of refinement of time scales is the appearance of circularity if people do not look at the source of the data carefully enough. Most commonly, this is characterised by oversimplified statements like: “The fossils date the rock, and the rock dates the fossils” (MacRae, 1998, emp. in orig.).
In what must be a somewhat embarrassing article for evolutionists, Tom Clarke authored an article in Nature, titled “Geologists Seek to Put an End to Blind Dates” (2003, 425:550). In the article Clarke commented, “Earth scientists have decided it is time to talk time.” He further lamented: “At a meeting in Washington D.C. last week, experts in mass extinctions, ancient climate and the art of dating rocks got together to work out plans for a more accurate and complete geological timescale” (p. 550, emp. added).
In addressing the incompleteness and inaccuracies in the fossil record Clarke admits: “That is partly because the most accurate techniques for dating are work-intensive and require more skill and money than most labs can spare” (425:550). So what do researchers often do? He continued: “So researchers often simply estimate rock ages by comparing the fossils found in one stripe of rock to another of known age” (425:550, emp. added).
Sounds an awful lot like “guesstimation” using circular reasoning, doesn’t it?
Clarke, Tom (2003), “Geologists Seek to Put an End to Blind Dates,” Nature, 425:550-551, October 9.
Hedges, Blair (2003), “The Coelacanth of Frogs,” Nature, 425:669-670, October 16.
MacRae, Andrew, (1998), “Radiometric Dating and the Geological Time Scale,” [On-line], URL: http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/dating. html.
Copyright © 2003 Apologetics Press, Inc. All rights reserved.
This document may be copied, on the condition that it will not be republished in print unless otherwise stated below, and will not be used for any commercial purpose, as long as the following stipulations are observed: (1) Apologetics Press must be designated as the original publisher; (2) the specific Apologetics Press Web site URL must be noted; (3) any references, footnotes, or endnotes that accompany the article must be included with any written reproduction of the article; (4) textual alterations of any kind are strictly forbidden; (5) Some illustrations (e.g., photographs, charts, graphics, etc.) are not the intellectual property of Apologetics Press and as such cannot be reproduced from our site without consent from the person or organization that maintains those intellectual rights; (6) serialization of written material (e.g., running an article in several parts) is permitted, as long as the whole of the material is made available, without editing, in a reasonable length of time; (7) articles, in whole or in part, may not be offered for sale or included in items offered for sale; and (8) articles may be reproduced in electronic form for posting on Web sites pending they are not edited or altered from their original written content and that credit is given to Apologetics Press, including the web location from which the articles were taken. Further, documents may not be copied without source statements (title, author, journal title), and the address of the publisher and owner of rights, as listed below.
For catalog, samples, or further information, contact:
230 Landmark Drive
Montgomery, Alabama 36117
Phone (334) 272-8558